Mal de debarquement syndrome caused by cervical spine instability

Ross Hauser, MD

If you are visiting this page, and you or a loved one have been diagnosed with Mal de debarquement syndrome, you do not need a long explanation of what this treatment is. In its simplest and most life-altering explanation, it is chronic and sustained motion sickness that lasts for years. It is much more likely that you are visiting this page looking for possible answers.

Mal de debarquement syndrome can be caused by health concerns beyond the main culprit of extended sea travel. For people who are not responsive to conventional treatments, I discuss how Mal de debarquement syndrome or non-motion-triggered Mal de debarquement syndrome may be caused by cervical spine instability.

Cervical spine instability is the result of damaged cervical ligaments. These neck ligaments which hold the cervical spine in place can become weakened or damaged by wear and tear motion, poor posture, EDS hypermobility, or accident injury. In this state, damaged cervical spine ligaments can cause a disruption of the normal activity of the proprioceptors, the motion and space sensory receptors that tell the brain about neck motion and the 3D perception of where the head is in space. If bad messages get to the brain as to where the proprioceptors think the head is, the brain will relay head movement commands based on this information and where it thinks the head is in space. Not where it actually is. The end result of this is the problem of chronic or sustained motion sickness that the brain and nerve receptors in the cervical spine create in their conflicting, confused, and sometimes panic messaging.

Later in this article, I will also discuss using Prolotherapy injections to repair these ligaments and how this treatment may alleviate or stop problems of motion sickness. We will also review a Digital Motion X-ray (DMX) of a patient who had constant “motion sickness,” EDS hypermobility, mast cell activation syndrome, and numerous disabling symptoms.

A story of Mal de debarquement syndrome

Mal de Debarquement (literally, bad disembarkment or exiting of a ship) Syndrome is a condition where individuals experience a chronic illusion of self-motion triggered by prolonged exposure to passive motion, such as from sea or air travel. The condition can be very disabling with episodes lasting greater than one month in 51% of patients and 18% lasting more than one year. There were significantly more migraine headache symptoms in patients who had the chronic form of the condition.

The symptoms of Mal de Debarquement are with you constantly; they never leave nor can they be alleviated by anti-motion sickness drugs. Some people say it seems “like trying to constantly walk on a mattress or trampoline.” The symptoms most frequently reported are:

Many of these symptoms overlap with other cervical instability syndromes including whiplash-associated disorder, post-concussion syndrome, and craniocervical syndrome, and atlantoaxial subluxation.

Before someone flies into our center, we have them send their records ahead of time to make sure they are a good candidate for our treatments. The screening process can be demanding but we want to make sure that before someone makes the trip to get our care they are a good candidate. Many of these people report dizziness, vertigo, lightheadedness, and disequilibrium, and while all have slightly different meanings, there is some overlap and many have structural causes. We are looking for the clues that the person’s problems are coming from a cervical or upper cervical instability that we can treat.

We saw a patient who had been seen at a dizziness and hearing clinic (balance clinic), where they noted that her symptoms of imbalance and aural fullness had been ongoing. At least six months in duration. Her symptoms also consisted of tilting, nausea upon lying down, double and blurred vision, and lightheadedness. The symptoms appeared in attacks, which usually lasted seconds to minutes and occurred roughly every two to three weeks. They usually came abruptly without warning. Triggers included standing up from sitting, rapid head movements, walking in a dark room, closed eyes and grocery stores, and narrow or wide-open visual spaces. She reported a history of headaches that had increased in the last six months. They occurred once or twice a week and lasted until she took pain medications. She had a history of fibromyalgia scleritis (autoimmune disorders). She had a history of back surgery and epidural injections. She reported an injury to her head (slight concussion), one month prior to her visit to the dizziness and hearing clinic.

Her diagnostic workup was negative except

Her diagnostic workup was negative except for her MRI of the brain which showed chronic microvascular (sometimes known as small artery disease or small vessel disease) ischemic (no known cause) changes. The radiologist said she correlated clinically for the Tullio phenomenon, a condition in which sounds induce a balance, equilibrium, or dizziness problem. It was clear from the office notes that she was being told everything was related to the brain so nothing could be done to cure the condition, but some balance exercises could help. Well, they didn’t help so she contacted us.

If one looks at this patient’s history, the possible best and obvious explanation of all of her symptoms would be cervical instability and the resultant proprioception (distortion of the sense of space and self-movement) and autonomic nervous system misinformation that is being sent to the brainstem and brain because of it. Her long history of headaches also makes it likely that her cervical instability is pretty significant. Motions of the neck absolutely make her symptoms worse, again pointing to a cervical etiology of her problem. As the patient had a history of neck issues, it is likely the rocking of the boat trip was the straw that broke the proverbial camel’s back in regard to her cervical instability. The body will do whatever it can to accommodate instability in order to reduce symptoms and increase stability, but there are times where no more adaptations can be made. At this point, the person has to get some type of neck stabilization otherwise the symptoms persist. Treatments are discussed below. But first, more on understanding how to get to the correct diagnosis.

The chase for a diagnosis, Mal de debarquement syndrome may be seen as one of many suspects causing your motion sickness.

In our many years of service helping people with cervical spine problems and the symptoms these challenges may cause, we have seen people who have visited with neurologists, audiologists, Ear Nose and Throat specialists, chiropractors, acupuncturists, stress management specialists, physical therapy specialists, and other health care providers seeking the information as to why do they sway or feel dizzy, or, feel like they are on a rocking boat.

Indeed, for some people, a specialist may ask them if they had been on a boat recently or maybe even surfing.

If the answer is no, no type of travel or voyage, then they like you, may have been initially diagnosed with:

The initial treatments for this condition are typically some type of medication. For many people, these medications are very helpful in managing these symptoms. These are typically not the people we see. We see people who may have limited or little success with medications and need other answers. Part of the challenge of supplying these answers is finding the right diagnosis. These above disorders share very similar symptom characteristics, while some medications will work for one problem, they may make another problem worse.

“Treatments have expanded beyond medication trials”

For the purpose of this article, we will try to focus on patients who have been diagnosed with Mal de debarquement syndrome and have not responded to treatment. Mal de debarquement syndrome and non-motion-triggered Mal de debarquement syndrome are considered two different entities. Successful treatment of Mal de debarquement syndrome may not be a successful treatment for non-motion-triggered Mal de debarquement syndrome. Often when these treatments fail, doctors may look away from Mal de debarquement syndrome and return to the previous diagnosis list mentioned above.

Is the problem an inner ear disorder? For some yes, not all.

In people we see, many of them who were suspected of having any of these disorders mentioned above, following extensive testing, perhaps without clear results, were put on medications. As mentioned previously, for many people medications may be very helpful. We typically see patients who did not have success with medication. However, for some of these people, the medications were able to eliminate the belief that they had other disorders like those mentioned above and helped focus their treatment on Mal de debarquement syndrome. Then again for these people, medications did not help their newly diagnosed Mal de debarquement syndrome either.

A January 2020 paper published in Seminars in Neurology (1)  from the Department of Neurology, Barrow Neurological Institute, and the University of Minnesota suggests how the treatment of Mal de debarquement syndrome is changing.

“Mal de debarquement syndrome is a disorder of persistent vertigo characterized by a feeling of oscillation such as rocking, bobbing, or swaying. It is triggered by passive motion, typically by exposure to water, air, or land transportation. This syndrome affects middle-aged individuals who are predominantly women. Mal de debarquement syndrome presents as a balance disorder that carries a significant risk of morbidity (health concerns) due to both the direct effects of balance impairment and associated symptoms of fatigue, cognitive slowing, and visual motion intolerance… more insight has been gained into the pathophysiology of morbidity, with current hypotheses pointing to a cerebral and cerebellar basis. Treatments have expanded beyond medication trials, and now include the use of noninvasive brain stimulation and readaptation of the vestibulo-ocular reflex. (The connection between a sense of balance in your inner ear and eye movement.)”

Optokinetic Stimuli as Treatment for Mal de Debarquement Syndrome

Optokinetic Stimuli as Treatment for Mal de Debarquement Syndrome

We are going to take a moment to discuss Optokinetic Stimuli. This is considered the first successful treatment for Mal de Debarquement Syndrome. This treatment is focused on people highly suspect of Mal de Debarquement Syndrome because they have had a recent trip, voyage, or activity on the water. The treatment is explained best by statements issued by the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai and leads research developer Mingjia Dai, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Neurology.

“Diagnostic tests and early research done at Mount Sinai suggested that Mal de debarquement syndrome was caused by malfunctioning of the vestibule-ocular reflex, a mechanism in the inner ear that maintains balance and stabilizes the eyes during head movements . . . (This)  treatment re-adapts the vestibule-ocular reflex by moving the visual surroundings as the head is slowly rolled from side to side at the same frequency as the subject’s symptomatic rocking, swaying or bobbing.”

In this research and treatment, Mal de Debarquement Syndrome cleared because the treatment focused on normalizing where the brain thought the head was in space compared to where the inner ear’s messages to the brain thought the head was. Focusing the eyes and rolling the head in the opposite direction to the sway corrected the problem.

In a case history report, (2) doctors at the U.S. Army Medical Center of Excellence, Army-Baylor University Doctoral Program in Physical Therapy, and the Department of Rehabilitation Medicine at Brooke Army Medical Center, Fort Sam Houston, Texas describe a 39-year-old female reported swaying and rocking after returning from a 7-day cruise. They discussed the treatment program that involves a passive role of the patient’s head while watching optokinetic stripes, resulting in the adaption of the vestibule-ocular reflex and improvement of Mal de debarquement syndrome.  The patient was treated with two sessions in a computer-assisted rehabilitation environment and symptoms resolved after two visits.

What if sustained motion, as in a sea cruise is not the cause of your Mal de debarquement syndrome? Do you even have Mal de debarquement syndrome? Yes, you can

Above is described situations where the onset of Mal de debarquement syndrome was brought on a sea cruise or other motions, but, what if sustained motion, as in a sea cruise, is not the cause of your Mal de debarquement syndrome? Do you even have Mal de debarquement syndrome?

“Recognizing the similarities and differences between motion-triggered and non-motion triggered Mal de Debarquement Syndrome can prevent unnecessary diagnostic testing and lead to earlier and more effective treatments.”

A May 2018 study (3) lead by the Laureate Institute for Brain Research and the University of Tulsa, questioned whether Mal de Debarquement Syndrome and non-motion triggered Mal de Debarquement Syndrome are actually two different disorders.

“There has been increasing awareness that post-motion triggered rocking self-vertigo can last for months or years, a disorder known as Mal de Debarquement Syndrome. A similar feeling of oscillating self-motion can occur without a motion trigger in some individuals, leading to controversy about whether motion-triggered and non-motion-triggered Mal de debarquement syndrome symptoms ultimately represent the same disorder. Recognizing the similarities and differences between motion-triggered and non-motion triggered  can prevent unnecessary diagnostic testing and lead to earlier and more effective treatments.”

In this study, researchers offered questionnaires to 80 individuals with persistent motion-triggered Mal de debarquement syndrome and non-motion triggered Mal de debarquement syndrome

Why Vestibular therapy did not work and other clues that point to Mal de debarquement syndrome as being caused by cervical spine instability in some patients

Above we discussed the research on medications, treating the problems of inner ear disorders to include Vestibular therapy, of which Optokinetic Stimuli is one, and therapy to move to head in opposite rotation to the sway people suffer from. What if all these treatments and therapies do not work and the patient still suffers symptoms? Failure of these treatments is our clue that the patient’s Mal de debarquement syndrome is a problem in the neck.

A case history presentation – a patient who has hypermobility Ehlers Danlos Syndrome (hEDS) and Mal de debarquement syndrome

Summary learning points and explanatory notes of this video

Dr. Hauser narrates the video below, a summary transcript is included.

Video: By the time the patient sought care with us she had pain in almost every body part. She was also previously diagnosed with mast cell activation syndrome, (immunological condition of repeated episodes of the symptoms of anaphylaxis (allergic reactions)). She had dizziness, tinnitus, and a list of other symptoms that clearly indicated that her nervous system was not working correctly.

Signals to the brain convey the wrong information of motion to the brain. Possible cause: Cervical spine ligament damage

Loss of natural cervical spine curve

Offset disconnect between cervical vertebrae

Digital Motion X-ray (DMX) demonstrates the patient’s neck problems

The loss of natural curvature of the cervical spine

Treating and repairing damaged cervical ligaments with Prolotherapy

In this image, we see a CT venogram in a patient with horrible dizziness. Both the sagittal and coronal planes show compression of the internal jugular vein by the lateral mass of the atlas (C1).

The cervical ligaments are strong bands of tissues that attach one cervical vertebra to another. In this role, the cervical ligaments become the primary stabilizers of the neck. When the cervical ligaments are healthy, your head movement is healthy, pain-free, and non-damaging. When the ligaments are suffering from degenerative wear and tear or excessive looseness or laxity that prevents the ligaments from holding the vertebrae together, the ligaments lose their ability to control the proper motion of your head. The head begins to move in a destructive, degenerative manner on top of your neck. When this occurs you can develop the symptoms of cervical vertigo, motion disorders, and dizziness.

Actual Prolotherapy treatment

Caring Medical has published dozens of papers on Prolotherapy injections as a treatment in difficult to treat musculoskeletal disorders. We are going to refer to our 2014 study mentioned earlier in this article, we published a comprehensive review of the problems related to weakened damaged cervical neck ligaments.

What we demonstrated in this study is that the cervical neck ligaments are the main stabilizing structures of the cervical facet joints in the cervical spine and have been implicated as a major source of chronic neck pain and in the case of Mal de debarquement syndrome type symptoms, cervical instability.

Prolotherapy is referred to as a regenerative injection technique (RIT) because it is based on the premise that the regenerative/reparative healing process can rebuild and repair damaged soft tissue structures. It is a simple injection treatment that addresses very complex issues.

This video jumps to 1:05 where the actual treatment begins.

This patient is having C1-C2 areas treated. Ross Hauser, MD, is giving the injections.

In 2015 our research team published our finding in our paper “The biology of prolotherapy and its application in clinical cervical spine instability and chronic neck pain: a retrospective study.” This peer-review research was published in the European Journal of Preventive Medicine. (5)

Here we wrote:In an effort to facilitate the diagnosis and treatment of clinical cervical spine instability and chronic neck pain, we investigated the role of proliferative injection Prolotherapy in the reduction of pain and recovery of constitutional and neurological symptoms associated with increased intervertebral motion, structural deformity and irritation of nerve roots. . . 95 percent of patients reported that Prolotherapy met their expectations in regards to pain relief and functionality.”

Caring Cervical Realignment Therapy (CCRT)

Caring Cervical Realignment Therapy (CCRT) was developed by Ross Hauser, M.D. after decades of treating patients with neck disorders, including cervical instability and degenerative disc disease.

Through extensive research and patient data analysis, it became clear that in order for patients to obtain long-term cures (approximately 90% relief of symptoms) the re-establishment of some lordosis, (the natural cervical spinal curve) in their cervical spine is necessary. Once spinal stabilization was achieved with Prolotherapy and the normalization of cervical forces by restoring some lordosis, lasting relief of symptoms was highly probable.

In this video Ross Hauser, MD explains Caring Cervical Realignment Therapy

The Horrific Progression of Neck Degeneration with Unresolved Cervical Instability

The Horrific Progression of Neck Degeneration with Unresolved Cervical Instability. Cervical instability is a progressive disorder causing a normal lordotic curve to end up as an “S” or “Snake” curve with crippling degeneration.

 

spine curves

Caring Medical

There are complex cases that can benefit from the individualized Dynamic Structural Medicine techniques that are unique to the Hauser Neck Center at Caring Medical Florida. Thus, our patients travel here from all over the world. Dr. Hauser is widely regarded as one of the most experienced Prolotherapists for complex upper cervical cases, and the upper cervical spine is an area that most Prolotherapists are not able to treat. If you have been looking for better answers to your medical questions, been dismissed by other facilities, and feel that your symptoms haven’t been taken seriously or properly diagnosed, we are available to review your case and see if we can help! We do have a multi-step process to assess if a patient is a good fit for our testing and treatment center. Please understand that we cannot accept every patient who inquires about care here. Dr. Hauser and his neck team review neck cases ahead of time to ensure they are coming to the ideal Caring Medical location for their case, as well as give you an idea of what to expect at your first visit to the neck center. Please reach out to us and we will direct you to which provider will be the optimal fit for your case.

Get help and information from our Caring Medical Staff

1 Saha K, Cha YH. Mal de Debarquement Syndrome. In Seminars in Neurology 2020 Jan 27. Thieme Medical Publishers. [Google Scholar]
2 Hoppes CW, Vernon M, Morrell RL, Whitney SL. Treatment of Mal de Debarquement Syndrome in a Computer-Assisted Rehabilitation Environment. Military Medicine. 2021 Feb 19.
3 Cha YH, Cui YY, Baloh RW. Comprehensive clinical profile of Mal De debarquement syndrome. Frontiers in neurology. 2018 May 7;9:261. [Google Scholar]
4 Steilen D, Hauser R, Woldin B, Sawyer S. Chronic neck pain: making the connection between capsular ligament laxity and cervical instability. The Open Orthopaedics Journal. 2014;8:326-345. [Google Scholar]
5 Ross Hauser, MD, Steilen-Matias D, Gordin K. The biology of prolotherapy and its application in clinical cervical spine instability and chronic neck pain: a retrospective study. European Journal of Preventive Medicine. 2015;3(4):85-102. [Google Scholar]

This page was last updated September 16, 2021

 

Make an Appointment |

Subscribe to E-Newsletter |

Print Friendly, PDF & Email
SEARCH
for your symptoms
Prolotherapy, an alternative to surgery
Were you recommended SURGERY?
Get a 2nd opinion now!
WHY TO AVOID:
★ ★ ★ ★ ★We pride ourselves on 5-Star Patient Service!See why patients travel from all
over the world to visit our center.
Current Patients
Become a New Patient

Caring Medical Florida
9738 Commerce Center Ct.
Fort Myers, FL 33908
(239) 308-4701 Phone
(855) 779-1950 Fax Fort Myers, FL Office
We are an out-of-network provider. Treatments discussed on this site may or may not work for your specific condition.
© 2021 | All Rights Reserved | Disclaimer