Craniocervical ligament injuries: Focus on the alar ligament
Ross Hauser, MD.
As with most cervical spine ligament injuries, the alar ligament injury takes its place among the controversial findings of difficult to treat and difficult to understand cervical spine instability. What makes the alar ligament injury so controversial? It centers around how important or non-important the alar ligament is in certain instances of cervical spine instability. As we are in the practice of healing ligaments, all ligaments are very important to us. But each ligament has a purpose and each ligament interacts with its surrounding ligaments, bones, and tendons. It is, as we have practiced and understood ligament healing, that a ligament works within a complex of ligaments. To fix one ligament, all the ligaments it interacts with should be treated as well. Ligament injuries are rare injuries that sit in isolation. General instability of the cervical spine is typically not a problem of a single ligament but an interaction of many.
In this article we will address the problem of chronic or post-traumatic ligament injury and the many neurologic, cardiovascular, psychiatric-type symptoms and conditions certain ligaments may present. We will see research that suggests that ligament injuries may be misunderstood, including the role of the alar ligament injury.
My doctors say the conditions and symptoms I have could not possibly exist
The idea that alar ligament injury is misunderstood is certainly not a new idea to people who have been diagnosed or suspected of having alar ligament “involvement.” Involvement of course being the MRI type word that many people have seen and read in their MRI interpretation of what is going on in their neck. Here are some of the types of stories we hear from people in their journey to understand their cervical spine instability and their alar ligament involvement:
My doctors have told me there is no treatment they can offer me at this point. I have been diagnosed with advanced cervical spine instability. I have been to several neurologists. They tell me that the symptoms I have of dizziness and vertigo, blurred and distorted vision, hyperacusis (sound disturbance or intolerance to sounds), occipital nerve pain and headache, are not coming from the advanced, degenerative problems in my neck. They are also not interested in talking about damaged ligaments. They also told me the conditions and symptoms I have could not possibly exist. There is no reason for them.
I have an MRI that demonstrates atlantoaxial instability, damage to the ligaments at c2, alar ligament, and the transverse ligament. I have bone spurs at c6/c7. The only treatment that they want to offer me is pain medications as there is not yet enough damage to my neck to warrant a fusion surgery.
I have an MRI that shows injury of my transverse and alar ligaments
Three years ago I was involved in an accident. I have seen many specialists and neurologists and now I am seeing pain management specialists. I am not getting any help. Almost any rotation or movement of my head will cause pain of varying degrees. I do however have constant pain in my right occipital area. I have an MRI that shows injury of my transverse and alar ligaments. The doctors I am seeing don’t want to treat C1-C2 and would prefer to limit treatments further down my cervical spine. I have had facet joint injections further down my spine and nerve ablation with no improvement.
The displaced C1
We will also hear the story of a chiropractic adjustment gone awry. The patient will be a regular, sometimes long-term patient of a favored chiropractor. One day there will be an adjustment that sets things in the wrong direction. In some people, this focuses on an adjustment of the C1. X-rays will reveal that the C1 is now displaced. Further chiropractic adjustments were able to put the C1 back in place but the adjustment does not hold for long. The patient then will report the familiar neurologic-type symptoms of dizziness, brain fog, general poor health, and pain.
Post-Concussion Syndrome and headaches
People will contact us following an impact to the head injury in which they suffered a concussion. At our center, we generally see one type of patient with a diagnosis of post-concussion syndrome. It is the patient who has long-term, unexplained conditions and symptoms and their post-concussion syndrome has now turned into a persistent post-concussion syndrome. Then this group of patients is further divided into The younger athlete with persistent post-concussion syndrome. The whiplash accident injury people with persistent post-concussion syndrome. The “I have had many concussions” people. For more information on this condition please see our article When persistent post-concussion syndrome turns into a neurologic mystery.
In these people, their initial contact with us will reveal that an MRI has been taken and that in their case the alar ligament(s) have been damaged in their impact injury. The focus on the alar ligament is being used as an explanation for the worsening of the post-concussion syndrome symptoms. Some of these people report that physical therapy and adjustments help a little and that they have taken to wearing a cervical collar to help minimize pain, discomfort, and constant headaches.
If we have these problems in people why is there controversy over the alar ligament involvement?
Above a very small sampling of the types of stories and medical histories we hear. We have seen many more complex cases. The question is, why is the alar ligament a focus of misunderstanding? Why will some doctors not understand its involvement? Let’s start trying to understand ourselves.
What are we seeing in this image? The interaction and relationships of the ligaments of the cervical spine
In this image, we are looking at an example of what may happen in a sports injury, whiplash injury, or accident involving the neck. In the heading of this image is a brief mention of MRI and DMX. Imaging tools to help identify cervical spine injuries. We will discuss this further below. Here the focus of this image is on the soft tissue.
In this image, we see two alar ligaments, the left side, and right side. For the purpose of this illustration, they are shown with class III type tears. We also see a dura mater / tectorial membrane complex tear III tear illustrated. This membrane acts as a ligament as it is an extension of the posterior longitudinal ligament. This membrane can be seen as a backup or redundancy system to help the alar and transverse ligaments stabilize the cervical spine. This is especially true in neck flexion or the motion of looking down with chin in the chest. The tectorial membrane helps prevent the odontoid process from moving backward and impinging into the cervical canal.
We also see injuries to the posterior atlantooccipital membrane or posterior atlantooccipital ligament. This ligament or membrane attaches the base of the skull to the atlas. A groove in this membrane offers just enough room to create an opening of the vertebral artery and suboccipital nerve.
How essential is the essential alar ligament?
At the top of this article, I stated that we treat ligament injury. Therefore every injury of a ligament needs to be addressed. Equally, the focus on treating a single ligament injury in isolation may not lead to the cervical spine instability that we are seeking.
Here is a paper that appeared in the Journal of Neurosurgery: Spine. February 2019 (1). Here a team of researchers from the Department of Bioengineering, and Scientific Computing and Imaging Institute, at the University of Utah created computer models to demonstrate that the occipitoatlantal capsular ligaments are the primary stabilizers of the occipitoatlantal joint in the craniocervical junction.
Here is what they said and did:
“There is contradictory evidence regarding the relative contribution of the key stabilizing ligaments of the occipitoatlantal joint.” Because cadaveric studies are limited by the nature and the number of injury scenarios that can be tested to identify occipitoatlantal stabilizing ligaments they developed a computer model to analyze five subject-specific craniocervical junction models to investigate the biomechanics of the occipitoatlantal joint and identify the ligamentous structures essential for stability.
The scenarios they created included: Isolated ligamentous injury of either decreasing the stiffness of the occipitoatlantal capsular ligaments (the ligaments of the facet joint at the back of the spine) or completely removing the transverse ligament, tectorial membrane, or alar ligaments. Combination scenarios were also evaluated.
Simply, what they tested for was how much instability would there be if the transverse ligament(s) was removed, how much instability there would be if the alar ligament(s) were removed. How much instability would there be if the occipitoatlantal capsular ligaments were “loosened.” Finally, how much instability would there be in combination with these simulations? Here are their results.
- “An isolated capsular ligaments injury resulted in the largest percentage increase in all ranges of motion (ROMs) at the occipitoatlantal joint compared with the other isolated injuries. Flexion, extension, lateral bending, and axial rotation significantly increased.”
Let’s stop here to discuss the capsular ligaments.
In 2014 our research team published a study in The Open Orthopaedics Journal (2). In this paper, we explained the role of the capsular ligaments in cervical spine instability. What the researchers above found out through the computer model, is what we discovered in clinical observation seen in our patients and a critical review of the medical literature up until that time.
“The capsular ligaments are the main stabilizing structures of the facet joints in the cervical spine and have been implicated as a major source of chronic neck pain. Chronic neck pain often reflects a state of instability in the cervical spine and is a symptom common to a number of conditions described herein, including disc herniation, cervical spondylosis, whiplash injury, and whiplash-associated disorder, post-concussion syndrome, vertebrobasilar insufficiency, and Barré-Liéou syndrome.
When the capsular ligaments are injured, they become elongated and exhibit laxity, which causes excessive movement of the cervical vertebrae. In the upper cervical spine (C0-C2), this can cause a number of other symptoms including, but not limited to, nerve irritation and vertebrobasilar insufficiency with associated vertigo, tinnitus, dizziness, facial pain, arm pain, and migraine headaches. In the lower cervical spine (C3-C7), this can cause muscle spasms, crepitation, and/or paresthesia in addition to chronic neck pain. In either case, the presence of excessive motion between two adjacent cervical vertebrae and these associated symptoms is described as cervical instability.
Therefore, we propose that in many cases of chronic neck pain, the cause may be underlying joint instability due to capsular ligament laxity.”
The two studies combined to express an agreement capsular ligament injury resulted in the largest percentage increase in all ranges of motion compared to other ligament injuries.
Let’s return to the Journal of Neurosurgery study for more findings:
- Among combination injuries, occipitoatlantal capsular ligaments + tectorial membrane + transverse ligament injury resulted in the most consistent significant increases in range of motion for both the occipitoatlantal joint and the Cranio Cervical Junction during all loading scenarios. Occipitoatlantal capsular ligaments + alar ligament injury caused the most significant percentage increase for occipitoatlantal joint axial rotation.
CONCLUSIONS These results demonstrate that the occipitoatlantal capsular ligaments are the key stabilizing ligamentous structures of the occipitoatlantal joint. Injury of these primary stabilizing ligaments is necessary to cause occipitoatlantal instability. Isolated injuries of transverse ligament, tectorial membrane, or alar ligaments are unlikely to result in appreciable instability at the occipitoatlantal joint.
Comment: The transverse ligament, the tectorial membrane, the alar ligaments are all very important structures in understanding and treating cervical spine instability. However, they are part of a vast array of cervical spine ligament and membrane weave that holds our head on our neck. Treating anything in isolation can result in diminished treatment results or no results at all.
What are we seeing in this image? A CT Scan showing the offset or subluxation of the C0-C1
Research: Many doctors do not understand the complexity of the craniocervical junction, neurological deficits, and why there is a normal CT
In the above image, we see a NOT normal CT scan of the C0-C1. There are obvious displacement and subluxation. We are now going to explore the crosstalk between doctors and researchers in understanding ligament problems in the craniocervical junction, the connection of skull, atlas, and axis, as they are revealed in imaging studies. Here we will discuss CT scans, MRIs, and Digital Motion X-Ray or DMX.
In June 2020, a team of radiologists writing in the Journal of Medical Imaging and Radiation Oncology (3) wrote: “Cervical spine trauma accounts for the majority of spinal injuries, and approximately one-third involve the craniocervical junction. Due to its high sensitivity, magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) has become the standard tool for imaging suspected ligamentous injuries in an unstable spine and in patients with neurological deficits having a normal CT. The ligamentous anatomy of the CCJ is complex, and thorough knowledge is a prerequisite for accurate interpretation of the MRI findings.”
Simply we have doctors having to rely on MRI to understand ligament injuries and for radiologists to understand the challenges of making an accurate interpretation.
These images are from a Digital Motion X-Ray
The digital motion x-ray is explained and demonstrated below. This is one of our tools in demonstrating cervical instability in real-time and motion. When you watch the video, you will see a moving image of this patient’s neck. This gives our clinicians insight into the patient’s range of motion where impingement or compression may be occurring.
- Digital Motion X-ray can be an excellent tool to show instability at the C1-C2 Facet Joints
- The amount of misalignment or “overhang” between the C1-C2 demonstrates the degree of instability in the upper cervical spine.
- This is treated with Prolotherapy injections (explained below) to the posterior ligaments that can cause instability.
- At 0:40 of this video, a repeat DMX is shown to demonstrate correction of this problem.
The challenges of cervical instability are many. Fixing cervical neck instability is not something that can be treated simply or easily, it takes a comprehensive non-surgical program to get the patient’s instability stabilized and the symptoms abated. We believe that if you have been going from clinician to clinician, practitioner to practitioner, doctor to doctor, there is a good likelihood that you have problems of cervical neck instability coming from weakness and damage to the cervical ligaments. Our treatments of Comprehensive dextrose Prolotherapy and in some cases Platelet Rich Plasma Prolotherapy can be an answer.
Prolotherapy is an injection of simple dextrose into the unstable cervical spine. The concept is that these injections will strengthen the cervical ligaments thereby providing a stronger or more stable connection between the cervical vertebrae.
In this video Ross Hauser, MD. discusses C0-C1 instability and the problems it creates on C1 nerve root compression.
The Occiput bone smashes against the C1 vertebra
At 0:50 video – the patient’s Digital Motion X-Ray demonstrates that their occiput is violently colliding with their C1 vertebra every time they move their head forward and their chin juts out.
Summary and contact us. Can we help you? How do I know if I’m a good candidate?
We hope you found this article informative and it helped answer many of the questions. Just like you, we want to make sure you are a good fit for our clinic prior to accepting your case. While our mission is to help as many people with chronic pain as we can, sadly, we cannot accept all cases. We have a multi-step process so our team can really get to know you and your case to ensure that it sounds like you are a good fit for the unique testing and treatments that we offer here.
1 Phuntsok R, Ellis BJ, Herron MR, Provost CW, Dailey AT, Brockmeyer DL. The occipitoatlantal capsular ligaments are the primary stabilizers of the occipitoatlantal joint in the craniocervical junction: a finite element analysis. Journal of Neurosurgery: Spine. 2019 Feb 15;30(5):593-601. [Google Scholar]
2 Steilen D, Hauser R, Woldin B, Sawyer S. Chronic neck pain: making the connection between capsular ligament laxity and cervical instability. The open orthopaedics journal. 2014;8:326. [Google Scholar]
3 Mantripragada S, Kannivelu A, Peh WC. Magnetic resonance imaging of cervical ligamentous anatomy and traumatic ligamentous injuries. Journal of medical imaging and radiation oncology. 2020 Jun;64(3):368-76. [Google Scholar]